covid: vaccines and delta household transmission
As per several prior articles, the SARS-CoV-2 Delta
variant is much more highly transmissible and has largely taken over the world.
This study assessed the viral transmission and viral load kinetics in both
vaccinated and unvaccinated people exposed to their vaccinated and uvaccinated
household contacts
(see covid delta transmission in vaccinated lancet2021
in dropbox, or doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099(21)00648-4)
Details:
-- 602 community contacts (identified in the UK contract-tracing
system) were identified from 471 index cases of symptomatic Covid-19, between
September 13, 2020 and September 15, 2021, with 8145 upper respiratory tract
samples from daily sampling for up to 20 days
-- 231 contacts
were exposed to 162 epidemiologically-linked Delta variant-infected cases
-- household and non-household contacts were included who were at
least 5 years old
-- median time between second vaccine dose and study recruitment
for fully vaccinated contacts was longer for infected individuals: 101 days
versus 64 days for uninfected individuals
-- PCR-positive participants: 55% female, 82% white, median age
36; all demographics similar among those with Delta, Alpha, and pre-alpha
infections (pre-alpha included infections from the Sept 13, 2020 to March 31,
2021 wave of infections in the UK), and for vaccinated or unvaccinated
Delta-infected participants, except for age and sex (fewer unvaccinated females
vs males, younger people were more likely infected with the Delta variant
probably from later rollout of vaccinations)
-- SARS-CoV-2 was detected in 163 of the 621 participants (26%),
and whole-genome sequencing of those PCR-positive confirmed:
-- Delta variant infection: 71 participants (18
index cases and 53 contacts): 23 (32%) were unvaccinated, 10 (14%) were
partially vaccinated, and 38 (54%) were fully vaccinated
-- Of the 38 vaccinated
Delta-infected participants, 14 had the Pfizer vaccine, 23 Aztec Zeneca, and 1
Sinovac
-- Alpha variant: 42 participants (one index
case and 41 contacts), one person was vaccinated
-- pre-alpha variants: 50 participants (all
contacts), none were vaccinated
-- primary outcome for epidemiologic analysis: viral load
trajectories from fully vaccinated individuals with Delta infection (n=29) as
compared to unvaccinated individuals with Delta (n=16), Alpha (n=39), and
pre-alpha (n=49)
-- primary outcome for viral load kinetics: differences in peak
viral load, viral growth rate, and viral decline rate between participants,
according to SARS-CoV-2 variant and vaccination status
Results:
-- secondary attack rate in household contacts:
-- fully vaccinated: 25% (18-33%)
-- unvaccinated: 38% (24-53%)
-- secondary attack rate in household contacts exposed to fully
vaccinated index cases:
-- fully vaccinated: 25% (15-35%)
-- unvaccinated: 23% (15-31%)
-- 12 (39%) of 31
infections in fully vaccinated household contacts were from fully vaccinated
epidemiologically-linked index cases, as confirmed by genomic and virologic
analysis
-- secondary attack rate for all Delta variant exposed contacts
was 26% (20-32%)
--this secondary attack rate was
not significantly higher in the unvaccinated at 38% (24-53%) vs fully
vaccinated at 25% (18-33%) [though an impressive trend to being different....]
-- peak viral loads: did not differ by vaccination status or
variant type, though did increase some as age increased from 10 to 50yo
--mean log10 viral load/ml was 8.14
(7.95-8.32) for 50yo adults, without much difference by variant or vaccination
status
-- Decline of viral load: faster decline was seen in those with
Alpha, unvaccinated Delta, and fully vaccinated Delta [though the only people
vaccinated were in the time of the Delta variant]
-- Increasing viral load: faster increases correlated with higher
peak viral loads and slower decline. A typical 3-day period was required for
the viral load to grow from undetectable to peak, though these growth rates
were slower in those in the vaccinated Delta group than in the pre-alpha group
Commentary:
-- this study found a few important things:
-- there was no difference in secondary attack
rates overall in household contacts exposed to a fully vaccinated index case
(25%) vs unvaccinated index case (23%) [though the only ones vaccinated were
during the Delta
variant time]
--there was only a relatively small difference in the secondary attack rate
with Delta variant from fully vaccinated index cases among household contacts
who were either vaccinated or not (25% vs 38%). This number for the Delta variant
is higher than in prior reports, eg in this
study it was 26%, but prior UK national surveillance data reported August 6,
2021 found 10.8% (the Delta variant was first found in UK in mid-April 2021.
was there a component of waning immunity in those getting vaccine that led to
this difference?? those contacts who were infected had a median 101 days after
second vaccine dose vs 64 days, though protection usually lasts that long). Many other studies have found higher transmission
rates with the Delta variant, likely associated with the higher viral loads
with the variant: see for example http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/2021/09/covid-delta-more-hosp-admissions-than.html
, or https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01986-w
. And this current study was still a pretty small study (small numbers
of people being infected in the household, which could
affect the accuracy of the secondary attack rates and leads to the
wide confidence intervals)
-- in prior studies, vaccination was
effective in reducing household transmission of the Alpha variant by 40 to 50%
and vaccinated individuals have lower viral loads in the upper respiratory
tract than unvaccinated. This study did not find much difference in peak
viral load between vaccinated and unvaccinated people with the Delta variant
(though this could be because they assessed viral load daily, and
one-time single-timepoint testing in prior studies may have distorted this
result by not sampling people at the same peak viral load time. or perhaps a
fluke finding from the small numbers of people involved)
-- so, a profound finding for the Delta virus since it
means that fully vaccinated people need to be as careful as unvaccinated people
in transmitting the virus to either vaccinated or unvaccinated people
around them, since they have a similar peak viral load and (related to that)
the same transmission rate
-- and, it should be emphasized that though vaccination does decrease the risk
of more severe Covid outcomes, continued transmission leads both to
prolongation of the pandemic as well as increased likelihood of development of
more vaccine escape variants. And in this context
finding transmission between vaccinated people and vaccinated contacts is quite
troublesome
--one issue here is that the risk of transmission depends on the
background rate of Covid in the specific community, both symptomatic and
asymptomatic. Which brings up a few issues:
-- in the US we do not have any systematic data
on asymptomatic or mild infections, per CDC decision several months ago. And,
testing for the virus is spotty and initiated by persons for a variety of
reasons (upcoming travel, employer mandate,…), including their own anxiety
(which varies dramatically from one person to the other)
-- for example, the New
York Times just reported that in terms of breakthrough infections in these
times of the Delta variant (see https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/10/28/us/covid-breakthrough-cases.html?referringSource=articleShare , data from
September 4), those who were unvaccinated had 6 times the rate of Covid
infection than those vaccinated, and 12 times higher risk of death. Though the
death estimate is likely pretty accurate, the former one is likely not, given
that there is no systematic testing or reporting of those with mild symptoms or
who are asymptomatic, there are data from only 14 states included in this
estimate, and there may be very different Covid testing rates for those who
elect to be tested between vaccinated and unvaccinated people
-- testing may also decrease in the upcoming
fall and winter months, as other upper respiratory viruses emerge (in the midst
of rhinovirus, RSV, flu, para-flu, maybe even the four recurring seasonal
coronavirus infections?)
-- in these months people are
probably more likely to attribute covid-related mild upper respiratory symptoms
to being “just a cold” and not pursue testing...
-- the data may be further distorted by the use
of medications to prevent serious covid-19 cases in those at higher risk, such
as the use of monoclonal antibodies. This would further decrease
hospitalizations and (I think) reporting Covid infections to the CDC
Limitations:
--the index cases in the study were all symptomatic people, so
unclear that these results were generalizable to those who were
asymptomatic
--no information about whether the household transmissions were
symptomatic or not, or if this varied by variant/vaccination status. Or if
any/which of the transmissions led to more severe Covid infections
--it is possible that the viral transmission in the household was
from a different contact person there, perhaps someone who was asymptomatic, so
the timed results found above might be misleading if the actual index case were
different from the one they targeted
--there was not much information about other factors associated
with the susceptibility of household contacts to become infected: eg other
viruses around, differences in the content of household interactions (use of
masks, distancing at home, ventilation in the house, time spent with contacts
and proximity to them, all of which might differ depending on differences of
the weather outside), underlying specific medical conditions/medications
of the infected person and the infected household
member,... All of these might affect the generalizability of their
conclusions
-- they did not assess virus viability by culture, though this is
not a definitive test that correlates with actual transmissibility; however,
prior small studies have found culturable virus from about 2/3 of vaccinated
people with Delta variant infection
So, given the pretty clear household transmissibility of the Delta variant
of SARS-CoV-2 even from fully vaccinated persons in contact with others who are fully
vaccinated, there are a few points:
--it is really important to use masks as much as possible. They
work!!! (http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/2021/09/covid-importance-of-masks-and.html ).
and this may be increasingly important as cold weather approaches with the
increased indoor contact and less open-window air circulation
--though not specifically tested above, the findings in the study
reinforce the importance of more global vaccination, including in children,
which does decrease the likelihood of getting severe Covid infection and
perhaps transmissibility (will need a bigger study to be sure)
--and, given the possibility that the higher transmission rates do occur at the time of waning
immunity, this study does support the potential clinical utility of booster
vaccines, though the data on the benefit of boosters are still unclear and
mostly based on less-than-compelling immunological data (see http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/2021/10/covid-mix-and-match-boosters-work-again.html ,
and http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/2021/09/covid-israeli-study-on-booster-not-so.html )
but are pretty suggestive of benefit
geoff
If you would like to be on the regular email list for upcoming blogs, please contact me at gmodest@uphams.org
to get access to all of the blogs (2 options):
1. go to http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/ to see them in reverse chronological order
2. click on 3 parallel lines top left, if you
want to see blogs by category, then click on "labels" and choose a
category
3. or you can just click on the magnifying
glass on top right, then type in a name in the search box and get all the
blogs with that name in them
or: go to https://www.bucommunitymedicine.org/ ,
a website from the Community Medicine section at Boston Medical Center.
This site does have a very searchable and accessible list of my blogs (though
there have been a few that did not upload over the last year or two). but
overall it is much easier to view blogs and displays more at a time.
please feel free to circulate this to others.
also, if you send me their emails, i can add them to the list
Comments
Post a Comment
if you would like to receive the near-daily emails regularly, please email me at gmodest@uphams.org