COVID: PPE effective on navy ship and for health care workers
A recent study reported in the MMWR assessed infections on a US naval ship, finding high prevalence, but also that PPE/distancing was helpful in decreasing spread, even in those living in close quarters (see https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6923e4-H.pdf )
Details:
-- the USS Theodore Roosevelt went to Guam after numerous US service members on board developed Covid-19
-- a convenience sample of 382 servicemembers (27% of 1117 servicemembers) aboard the aircraft carrier voluntarily completed a questionnaire and provided serum specimens; 267 (70%) also provided nasopharyngeal swabs. Approximately 1000 of the servicemembers were determined to be infected with SARS-CoV-2 [i'm not sure how this 1000 fits with the numbers below]
-- 76% male, median age 30, 58% non-Hispanic white, 7% reported history of asthma/hypertension/diabetes/immunosuppression
-- symptoms reported (only reporting those with odds ratio is greater than 2)
-- loss of taste/smell/or both: OR 10.31 (5.26-20.21)
-- palpitations: OR 3.15 (0.91-10.93)
-- fever: OR 2.79 (1.58-4.90):
-- chills: OR 2.73 (1.54-4.84)
-- myalgias: OR 2.56 (1.52-4.32)
-- there was an increased likelihood of Covid-19 as the number of symptoms increased, with a maximum OR of 4.48 (2.15-9.37) for those with at least 8 symptoms
-- there was also an increased incidence of infection in those who had contact with someone known to have Covid-19 (64%) vs those who did not (42%), OR 2.5 (1.1-5.8)
-- there was also increased risk in those sharing a sleeping berth with a person positive for SARS-CoV-2: 66% vs 36%, OR 3.3 (1.8-6.1)
-- serum was tested for IgG through ELISA assays, as an indicator of previous SARS-CoV-2 exposure; positive samples were further assessed for neutralizing antibodies
-- 238 (62%) reported previous or current SARS-CoV-2 infection, 194 (82%) reported one or more symptoms, 44 (19%) were asymptomatic, 2 (1%) were hospitalized for Covid-19 [i.e., most either had mild symptoms or were asymptomatic]
Results:
-- Lower odds of infection were associated with self-reported:
-- wearing a face covering: 56% vs 81%, OR 0.3 (0.2-0.5)
-- avoiding common areas: 54% vs 68%, OR 0.6 (0.4-0.9)
-- observing social distancing: 55% vs 70%, OR 0.5 (0.3-0.8)
-- antibodies: 228 (60%) had a positive ELISA assay; 135 (59% of these) also had a positive neutralizing antibody, more so in Latinx participants (75%)
-- 267 had an NP swab: 98 (37%) had a positive PCR, 171 (64%) had a positive ELISA
-- of the 235 who had a prior positive SARS-CoV-2 result, 90% had positive ELISA result vs 11% among 147 not reporting a previous positive SARS-CoV-2 result [ie the ELISA test seemed to miss 10% who stated they had a prior positive PCR]
-- of 12 people with positive ELISA results >40 days after symptom onset, 8 maintained their positive neutralization antibody results (including 2 people who tested >3 months after symptom onset)
Commentary:
-- it was pretty striking that two thirds of the servicemembers had positive ELISA results suggesting prior infection, and one third had positive PCR results with 19% being asymptomatic (as a frame of reference, prior studies suggests that antibodies develop a median of 11 days after symptoms and longer for more virus-specific antibodies, including the high affinity neutralizing antibodies)
--this study did not track people over time. some of the asymptomatic people may have been presymptomatic (ie, symptoms to come)
-- about half of those with positive ELISA results also had neutralizing antibodies; there was evidence of neutralizing antibodies > 3 months after symptom onset, suggesting at least short-term protection from reinfection.
--As per prior blogs, we do not know what antibodies are actually protective in people, if any, or for how long. neutralizing antibodies are a strong candidate, but they only seemed to happen in about 1/2 those infected above (though small numbers of people). My guess is that this will become clearer in the second wave of infections, when we actually will be able to see how many of those with prior infection get reinfected.....
--a prior study with a complete longitudinal survey of 217 people on a cruise ship (the Shackleton re-enactment), of whom 60% tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, 81% were asymptomatic. And early on in the pandemic, the Diamond Princess cruise ship found that 18% remained asymptomatic. in addition, a detailed Chinese study found that 42% of patients were asymptomatic, though fortunately shed virus for less time than those who were symptomatic (see http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/2020/06/covid-asymptomatic-infections-and-viral.html )
-- this article confirmed the very high likelihood of Covid-19 infection in those who develop anosmia, though the lack of anosmia does not rule out Covid-19
-- as with cruise ships, those on an aircraft carrier have intense exposure to others and a high likelihood of SARS-CoV-2 transmission (though a large percentage seem to be or remain asymptomatic)
Limitations of study:
-- this was a convenience sample, and there may well have been selection bias (vs the Shackleton cruise, where everyone was tested and followed)
-- all information was based on self-report, and liable to error
-- there are no documented temporal data on previous positive results for SARS-CoV-2
-- there were no rigorous data on the data symptom onset, information on timing, duration, and severity of individual symptoms
-- the study involved cross-sectional data at a point in time and may underestimate the future development of antibody responses
-- Another article confirmed the protective effects of PPE and healthcare professionals in China (see covid PPE healthcare workers work BMJ2020 in dropbox, or d oi.org/10.1136/bmj.m2195), finding that of 420 healthcare professionals (116 doctors and 304 nurses) in Wuhan wearing appropriate personal protective equipment, but working 4-6 hour shifts for an average of 5 days per week including 16 hours per week in intensive care units: none of these health care workers reported Covid-19 symptoms, and subsequent testing showed none had positive PCR or IgG/IgM antibodies
So, this study suggests a few things:
-- even in the confines of a ship with a high prevalence of SARS-CoV-2, social distancing, wearing a face mask, and avoiding common areas significantly decreased the risk of infection
-- and the healthcare worker in China study was quite reassuring regarding the protection of personal protective equipment in a very high risk situation
-- as more reports come out, it is clear that anosmia seems to be a signal symptom in the diagnosis of Covid-19, though lack of the symptom does not rule out Covid
-- we really do need to have more reliable extensive data on the prevalence of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 in the population, if it is transmissible (either epidemiologically as found in some smaller studies or by proxy of positive viral cultures), and for how long. we really do not have robust enough data to assert that asymptomatic people have a lower likelihood of transmission (the WHO statement, widely quoted that there is less transmission, is not based on good data: they note that the data from "cases without symptoms comes form a limited number of studies with small samples that are subject to possible recall bias and for which fomite transmission cannot be ruled out". see https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/advice-on-the-use-of-masks-in-the-community-during-home-care-and-in-healthcare-settings-in-the-context-of-the-novel-coronavirus-(2019-ncov)-outbreak
If you would like to be on the regular email list for upcoming blogs, please contact me at gmodest@uphams.org
to get access to all of the blogs:
1. go to http://gmodestmedblogs.blogspot.com/ to see them in reverse chronological order
2. click on 3 parallel lines top left, if you want to see blogs by category, then click on "labels" and choose a category
3. or you can just click on the magnifying glass on top right, then type in a name in the search box and get all the blogs with that name in them
please feel free to circulate this to others. also, if you send me their emails, i can add them to the list
Comments
Post a Comment
if you would like to receive the near-daily emails regularly, please email me at gmodest@uphams.org